Skip to main content

Grilled Turkey Tenderloin With Brown Sugar And Whole Grain Mustard

#MakeItGAP Recipes - Recipes using farm animal welfare labeled G.A.P. products
Grilled Turkey Tenderloin With Brown Sugar And Whole Grain Mustard

Grilled Turkey Tenderloin With Brown Sugar And Whole Grain Mustard

MAKES: 6-8 Servings
PREP TIME: 1 Hour 15 Minutes
COOK TIME: 40 Minutes
TOTAL TIME: 1 Hour 55 Minutes

Recipe adapted from
Original publication date July 31, 2020


3 lbs. turkey tenderloins (approximately 3/4 lb. each)
1/2 cup packed brown sugar
1/2 cup whole grain mustard
1 Tbsp. apple cider vinegar
1 tsp. cumin
1 tsp. black pepper
1/2 tsp. smoked paprika
1/2 tsp. garlic powder
1/2 tsp. kosher salt


In a medium bowl, whisk the brown sugar, whole grain mustard, apple cider vinegar, cumin, black pepper, smoked paprika, garlic powder, and kosher salt. Reserve 1/3 cup of mixture to drizzle over turkey right before serving.

Place turkey tenderloins in a medium bowl or pan that is low and wide. Pour remaining brown sugar and
mustard mixture over the top and turn tenderloins to coat completely. Cover bowl/pan with plastic wrap
and refrigerate tenderloins for 1 hour.

Remove from refrigerator, uncover, and let sit on counter while heating the grill.

Heat grill to high heat. Make sure grates are scrubbed clean and then oiled. (To oil the grates, add some canola oil to a small bowl. Then fold a heavy paper towel a few times to make a smaller square. With a tongs, grasp the folded paper towel and dip it into the oil until the paper towel is drenched. Then run the paper towel over the grates, repeating until all grill grates are thoroughly oiled.) Next, turn heat down to medium-high. Place “beauty” side of each turkey tenderloin face-down on the grill grates. Sear for about 4 minutes, until there are charred grill lines. Using a metal turner, carefully turn each tenderloin over, taking care to not tear the turkey surface by gently working the turner to scrape and lift turkey from grates. Reduce heat to medium and grill for about 8 minutes. Rotate tenderloins on same side (don’t flip them over – you want to preserve those pretty grill marks!) after 5 minutes. Then reduce heat to medium low and grill until internal temperature of thickest part of tenderloins reaches 160° F. Grill time should be about 40 minutes total, for tenderloins that weigh about 3/4 pound each. Adjust all times for tenderloins that are larger or smaller.

Remove tenderloins to a platter to rest for 5 minutes before slicing. Slice tenderloins and then drizzle reserved brown sugar and whole grain mustard mixture over the top. Serve hot to warm.

Animal Welfare Certified Label - Global Animal Partnership
Look for the label and
#MakeitGAP when
you shop! Learn more
about our label here.